What's the Safest Cookware?

2021-12-25 02:00:00 By : Ms. Jerry Nie

You've likely read about the dangers of nonstick cookware — chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) get released into your food during the cooking process and cause all sorts of health problems. So it can be difficult to choose pots and pans. You want something that's safe, but it would be nice if it were also easy to clean.

Data gathered, studies compared, and all options dutifully considered, here is an overview of the health and environmental impacts of common cookware options. Keep the larger picture in mind as you peruse your cookware options:

Reduce. Buy only what you need. Look for items that can do double-duty and buy for longevity.

Reuse. If you buy cookware, buy used.

Recycle. Find new uses for your old pots and pans.

When weighing health and environmental issues, remember that in the U.S., chemicals and other products are generally considered safe until proven otherwise. Is there irrefutable proof that nonstick pans can cause cancer, or that aluminum cookware could be a factor in Alzheimer’s disease? No. We are lab rats, caught somewhere between the uncertainties and linguistics of science and regulatory principles that place potential health and environmental threats — and the burden of proving those threats — on the public. We are canaries in the kitchen.

Health concerns are often the number one issue when choosing pots and pans. Here's how the different types stack up.

This is the most popular cookware and also the most controversial. According to the Environmental Working Group, nonstick coatings can reach 700 degrees Fahrenheit in as little as two to five minutes, releasing 15 toxic gases and chemicals, including two carcinogens. At high heat the fluoropolymers used in nonstick finishes release various toxic substances.

The greatest concerns surround perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), a substance that persists in the environment and widespread use of which has made it detectable in the blood of almost all Americans, adults and newborns alike. PFOA is considered a likely carcinogen and is associated with raised levels of cholesterol and birth defects.

Additionally, overheated chemical nonstick finishes release fumes that cause an illness in humans known as polymer fume fever. The fumes are known to kill birds, and manufacturers warn against use of these pans in homes with pet birds—hence the "canary in a coal mine" reference. Most Americans have at least one piece of chemical nonstick cookware, and they are urged to follow these safety guidelines:

This option is a mixture of different metals, including nickel, chromium and molybdenum. These metals can migrate into foods, but unless your cookware is worn or damaged the amount of metals likely to get into your food is reportedly negligible.

As with nonstick surfaces, it is suggested you avoid using abrasives for cleaning stainless steel cookware.

Aluminum is a soft and highly reactive metal that can leach into food, especially when you are cooking with acidic ingredients. The metal-food reaction can form aluminum salts that are associated with impaired visual motor coordination and Alzheimer’s disease. Aluminum is ubiquitous—it is the third most abundant element in the earth's crust and can be found in the air, water and soil. Aluminum intake is virtually impossible to avoid, and the amount we are likely to get from aluminum cookware is relatively minimal. This has led to a cookware-is-the-least-of-our-worries stance. Approached from a more precautionary view, why wouldn’t we take every opportunity to limit exposure, at least until we have reliable evidence of aluminum’s safety?

As with other cookware, the more pitted and worn the pot, the greater the amount of aluminum that can be absorbed. Because aluminum is so reactive, cooking or storing highly acidic or salty foods may cause more aluminum than usual to enter the food.

This has become a popular alternative to plain aluminum. Aluminum placed in a chemical solution and exposed to electric current builds up a hard, non-reactive surface. This process is called anodization. The electrochemical anodizing process “locks in” the aluminum, but anodization can break down over time.

Cast-iron is known for its durability and even heat distribution. Unglazed cast iron can transfer notable amounts of iron into food, but unlike the metals that come off other types of pots and pans, iron is considered a healthy food additive by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The nonstick quality of cast iron comes from seasoning. Seasoning is the term used for treating cast iron with oil and baking it. This fills in the porous surface of the cookware. A guide to seasoning cast iron is available here.

Copper leaches into food when heated, prompting the FDA to caution against using unlined copper for general use.  Accordingly, the cooking surfaces are usually lined with tin, nickel or stainless steel. Coated copper cookware can lose its protective layer if damaged or scoured. Keep in mind that the metals of the “protective” surface can also end up in your food.

These are generally safe options. Health concerns about using ceramic and enamel stem from components used in making, glazing or decorating the cookware, such as lead or cadmium. In the U.S., both of these highly toxic substances have been phased out, or at least limited in cookware manufacturing. This is not a place to ignore labels; if it says "Not for food use," don't use it for food!

This simply shouldn’t be an option.

Bamboo is non-reactive and considered to have no harmful effects on food, but its uses are limited: You can’t fry eggs in bamboo.

The materials used to create cookware have varying degrees of impact on the environment. You may want to keep that in mind when choosing your pots and pans.

Metals carry a heavy burden of resource extraction, processing and manufacturing. Mining is a dirty and destructive process, and the manufacturing of complex, multiple-metal cookware is energy-intensive. Most metals can be recycled, but the mixing of elements (stainless coated copper, for example) can negate that quality. Coatings and nonstick linings break down with use and time, so these pans are short-lived. Some interesting ideas for reusing metal cookware can be found here.

A renewable resource, bamboo does not necessitate mining and uses relatively little energy in manufacturing.  Bamboo cookware has a short lifespan, but its environmental impact is relatively small.

Glass, ceramic, and enameled cookware generally cannot be recycled. They can be bought used and depending on the quality, and can be versatile enough to serve multiple functions. Their longevity is limited by breakage.

Cookware made of cast-iron can last for many, many generations. It can be bought used and still be as good as new — or better. It can be used on the stovetop or in the oven, reducing the number of items used for cooking. It requires no detergent for cleaning. It’s a winner.

I think cast-iron is the best option all around. Weigh the health and environmental risks and decide what is best for you.

Krimsky, Sheldon. "The Unsteady State And Inertia Of Chemical Regulation Under The US Toxic Substances Control Act.” PLoS Biol, vol. 15, 2017, doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.2002404

“Perfluorooctanoic Acid (PFOA), Teflon, and Related Chemicals.” American Cancer Society.

“Canaries in the Kitchen.” Environmental Working Group.

“Are You Cooking with These? Cookware Considerations.” Minnesota Pollution Control Agency.

“Drinking Water Health Advisory for Perfluorooctanoic Acid (PFOA).” U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

Shimizu, Taro, et al. “Polymer Fume Fever.” BMJ Case Reports, 2012, doi10.1136/bcr-2012-007790

McKeen, Laurence T. “Is Today’s Non-stick Cookware Safe?.” New Materials & Applications, Elsevier, 2017

Farrell, Mary H.J.. “Best Frying Pans for the Way You Cook.” Consumer Reports. Published December 4, 2020.

“Keep Teflon, Avocado, Lead, and Zinc Away From Pet Birds.” University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign College of Veterinary Medicine.

Kamerud, Kristin L., et al. “Stainless Steel Leaches Nickel and Chromium into Foods During Cooking.” J Agric Food Chem, vol. 61, no. 39, 2013, pp. 9495-9501., doi:10.1021/jf402400v

Sandbeck, Ellen. Organic Housekeeping In Which the Non-Toxic Avenger Shows You How to Improve Your Health and That of Your Family, While You Save Time, Money, And, Perhaps, Your Sanity. Scribner, 2007.

“What You Should Know about Aluminum.” Texas Department of State Health Services.

Kawahara, Masahiro, and Midori Kato-Negishi. “Link Between Aluminum and the Pathogenesis of Alzheimer’s Disease: the Integration of the Aluminum and Amyloid Cascade Hypotheses.” International Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease, 2011, pp. 1-17., doi:10.4061/2011/276393

Exley, Christopher. Aluminum in Biological Systems. Encyclopedia of Metalloproteins. doi:10.1007/978-1-4614-1533-6_105

Stahl, Thorsten, et al. “Migration of Aluminum from Food Contact Materials to Food—a Health Risk For Consumers? Part III Of III: Migration of Aluminum to Food from Camping Dishes and Utensils Made of Aluminum.” Environ Sci Eur, vol. 29, no. 17, 2017., doi:10.1186/s12302-017-0117-x

Runge, Jude Mary. The Metallurgy of Anodizing Aluminum Connecting Science to Practice. Springer International Publishing, 2018.

“Cooking Utensils and Nutrition.” U.S. National Library of Medicine MedlinePlus.

“Food Additive Status List.” U.S. Food & Drug Administration.

“Elemental Analysis: Orientation and Training IV Section 6.” U.S. Food & Drug Administration. Updated June 30, 2020.

“Import Alert 52-08.” U.S. Food & Drug Administration. Published January 25, 2021.

Chongtham, Nirmala, et al. “Nutritional Properties of Bamboo Shoots: Potential and Prospects for Utilization as a Health Food.” Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, vol. 10, 2011, pp. 153-168., doi:10.1111/j.1541-4337.2011.00147.x

Söderholm, Patrik, and Tomas Ekvall. “Metal Markets and Recycling Policies: Impacts and Challenges.” Miner Econ, vol. 33, 2020, pp. 257–272., doi:10.1007/s13563-019-00184-5

Nayak, Lopamudra, and Siba Prasad Mishra. “Prospect Of Bamboo as a Renewable Textile Fiber, Historical Overview, Labeling, Controversies and Regulation.” Fash Text, vol. 3, 2016, doi:10.1186/s40691-015-0054-5

There was an error. Please try again.

Thank you for signing up.